Taking the field: Footballers who died in the World Wars

We remember the Commonwealth international footballers who gave their lives in the World Wars.

Footballers at war

International footballers serving in the ranks

On the face of it, footballers have many attributes that would make them ideal soldiers:

• They’re fit, active young men in the prime of their lives
• They already know about the value of teamwork in competitive environments and the power of the bonds forged
• They have a cutting edge that makes them want to win and succeed at all costs

Indeed, many thousands of professional players would enlist during the World Wars, joining many other athletes serving in wartime.

During both conflicts, football was used by enlisted men for some much-needed recreation.

Regiments, battalions, companies, ships, and squadrons all formed their own sides for friendly competition to help blow off some steam after their frontline service.

Then there is the now legendary Christmas Truce football match. Yuletide 1914 brought a miraculous day of peace and reconciliation for some of the Imperial German and British troops facing each other in Belgium and northern France.

A letter published in the 1^st of January 1915 edition of The Times from a Royal Medical Corps officer suggests his regiment played against Saxons, resulting in a (typical) 3-2 victory for the Germans.

While there is little corroborating evidence to suggest the event happened, one German lieutenant, Johannes Niemann of the 133rd Infantry Regiment, also wrote of it. Many soldiers wrote about attempts to arrange a match between the two warring powers as well.

It’s more likely that some impromptu kickabouts occurred up and down the line in places where the guns fell silent on Christmas Day.

Whatever the truth about a proper match (3-2!), the stories go to show the power of football and sport in bringing people together even in the most extraordinary circumstances.

The Great War and the birth of the Football Battalions

Image: A recruitment poster for the Football Battalions (Wikimedia Commons)

Between 1915-1919, professional football was cancelled. Exhibition matches and tournaments would continue to take place, but manpower needs meant every available man was expected to take part in the war effort.

Professional clubs, whose livelihood at that point relied almost entirely on match day takings, were against having their talents serve and games suspended. Public opinion began to turn against football clubs.

There was even a suggestion that King George V should remove his patronage from the Football Association.

However, politician William Joynson-Hicks organised the 17^th (Service) Battalion as part of the Middlesex Regiment in December 1914. The Football Battalion was born with England international Frank Buckley being the first professional to enlist.

A second Football Battalion, the 23^rd (Service) Battalion was formed in 1915 with former Tottenham Hotspur player Alan Haig-Brown assigned as its commanding officer in 1916.

Entire teams signed up. Leyton Orient – then Clapham Orient – signed up to fight as one, as did the Heart of Midlothian squad from Edinburgh, who served with the 16^th Royal Scots (McCrae’s Battalion).

At the breakout of the Great War, there were around 5,000 professional footballers in England and Wales. By the war’s end, 2,000 or so signed up to serve. Approximately 300 would lose their lives during the conflict.

Speaking of the professional footballers who served in his unit, the 17th (Service) Battalion's Commander Colonel H.T. Fenwick said:

Football during World War Two

Competitive football was cancelled in the UK once again during World War Two. Professional footballers all had their contracts terminated for the duration of the war.

Even so, footballers still signed up to serve in large numbers relative to their profession’s small number. According to Picture Post magazine, 629 professionals had joined the armed forces, the majority of them the British army, in 1940 alone.

Some of those considered the best British footballers of all time saw service. The “Wizard of the Dribble” Sir Stanley Matthews and Preston North End legend Sir Tom Finney served in the Royal Air Force and British Army respectively, for instance.

Competitions, such as the Wartime League and Wartime Cup, and exhibition matches were organised. For example, England played 29 internationals against Wales and Scotland between 1939-1945.

Football played the same role as it had in the Great War: a way for service personnel to relax and to entertain themselves during their downtime, and a way to relieve the monotony of war work and rationing for civilians, with exhibition matches taking place up and down the country.

Stories of Fallen Footballers

James Williams

Image: James "Ginger" Williams in his Crystal Palace kit (Wikimedia Commons)

Upon the sombre limestone panels of the Arras Memorial, you’ll find over 34,000 soldiers whose bodies were never recovered. These men died in and around the crucial French city where the Memorial sits, Arras, which sits upon a network of deep, winding tunnels.

If you’re a football aficionado with a familiarity with the game’s early days, you might recognise the name John Williams, better known as James “Ginger” Williams.

James was like many who donned the red shirt of Wales and took to the field: a skilled yet fairly unremarkable player, dwarfed by the talents of some of his international colleagues. However, the stocky forward was not without spirit, hard work or an eye for goal.

During his time with Crystal Palace between 1909-1914, he scored 58 goals in 142 appearances. While Palace was playing in the lower leagues at the time, James’ tally is still a very impressive return. Perhaps James’ greatest on-field moment came against Southend United in September 1909 when the diminutive Welshman scored five times.

James’ fighting spirit and wholehearted approach to the game earned him the nickname “The Palace Terrier”. It also earned him two calls up to the Wales national team, where he played alongside such luminaries as Manchester United’s Billy Meredith.

James had started a new chapter in his playing career when he joined Millwall in 1914. By then, war had come calling.

James left his wife, Sarah, and young son Kenneth, behind to join the 17th (Service) Battalion of the Middlesex Regiment, aka the Football Battalion, to serve in Northern France in 1915.

By 1916, James had transferred to the Royal Engineers, taking on the dangerous duties as a sapper. Ultimately, his role with the Royal Engineers claimed his life when he was killed in a mine explosion in June 1916.

James’ death was widely reported, including a report in the New York Times. As well as his commemoration on the panels of the Arras Memorial, James Williams is also remembered at Millwall’s home ground The Den.

Jimmy Speirs

Image: Scotland international, FA Cup winner and Military Medal recipient Jimmy Speirs (Wikimedia Commons)

Across 226 appearances, Jimmy Speirs scored 96 career goals.

Born in Govan, Glasgow, the Scottish forward began showing signs of early promise playing in the blackened ash pits of Govanhill. Eventually, he would turn pro and play for one of Scotland’s biggest clubs: Glasgow Rangers.

Despite finding the net 24 times in 53 games, including a hattrick in a 7-1 drubbing of Arthurlie in the Scottish Cup, Rangers were in a trophy drought during Jimmy’s playing days.

Even without earning any silverware, Jimmy’s performances at Rangers earned him a Scotland cap in a 2-1 win over Wales in March 1908.

Jimmy joined fellow Scottish club Clyde in 1908 before moving south to play for Bradford in 1909.

During his three-year spell with the Yorkshire club, Jimmy scored 29 goals in 86 appearances. His greatest footballing triumph came with Bradford when the team bested Newcastle United in the 1911 FA Cup final replay. Jimmy headed home the winning goal himself.

Jimmy Speirs part in Bradford’s FA Cup triumph made him a legend. Over 100,000 Bradfordians flocked to the victory parade, seeing Jiimmy and his beaming smile as he triumphantly held the trophy aloft.

Jimmy left Bradford in 1912 to play out the final three years of his footballing career with Leeds City. He left Leeds with a further 32 goals.

With football suspended, Jimmy responded to the call for volunteers and joined up with the Queen’s Own Cameron Highlanders in May 1915. Conscription was still a year away. If he’d have waited, Jimmy would have been exempt from service as he was married with two young children.

This wasn’t the case and Jimmy was soon serving with his regiment’s 3^rd Battalion. Casualties overseas prompted Jimmy’s promotion to Lance Corporal during training.

Jimmy was posted overseas in May 1916. He would soon establish himself as a battlefield leader, mirroring his footballing heroics and leadership abilities. He reached Corporal soon after he reached France but took an elbow wound later in 1916.

1917. The Second Battle of Arras. Jimmy’s exploits during this chaotic and costly campaign resulted in a Military Medal for bravery. The citation describing his deeds is unfortunately lost, but he was promoted to Sergeant soon after.

Unfortunately, the gallant Scot would not survive the war. Caught amid the blood, mud and wire of the Third Battle of Ypres at Passchendaele, a bullet struck Jimmy in the thigh. He managed to find shelter in a shell crater and was given medical assistance, but his regiment was forced to move on.

Jimmy was never seen alive again.

Sergeant Jimmy Speirs, decorated soldier and one of Bradford City’s most beloved players, is buried in Dochy Farm New British Cemetery in Belgium.

Donald Simpson Bell VC

Image: A cigarette card of Donald Simpson Bell in his military uniform (Wikimedia Commons)

Harrogate-born Donald Simpson Bell holds two major distinctions that separate him from other professional footballers that served in the Great War.

Firstly, the former Newcastle United, Crystal Palace and Bradford (Park Avenue) FC player was the first professional player to join the British Army, ahead of the formation of the Football Battalions.

Donald enlisted in the West Yorkshire Regiment in early 1915. He was quickly promoted to Lance Corporal and eventually commissioned as a Second Lieutenant in the Green Howards (Alexandra, Princess of Wales’ Own Yorkshire Regiment).

While on leave in June 1916, Donald married Rhoda Margaret, but any thoughts of long-term marital bliss were shattered for the couple. Donald was called back to the Front ahead of the ill-fated, bloody Battle of the Somme.

Initially, the Green Howards 9^th Battalion were held in reserve for the titanic clash to come but were ordered to the front on 5^th July 1916.

During the raging fighting, Donald earned his second important distinction: The Victoria Cross, Britain’s highest military honour.

Donald’s Victoria Cross citation reads:

“For most conspicuous bravery. During an attack a very heavy enfilade fire was opened on the attacking company by a hostile machine gun. 

“2nd Lt. Bell immediately, and on his own initiative, crept up a communication trench and then, followed by Corpl. Colwill and Pte. Batey, rushed across the open under very heavy fire and attacked the machine gun, shooting the firer with his revolver, and destroying gun and personnel with bombs.

“This very brave act saved many lives and ensured the success of the attack. Five days later this very gallant officer lost his life performing a very similar act of bravery.”

According to a letter Donald wrote to his parents, his actions were just a fluke. Even if he was being modest, there’s not doubt Donald’s actions helped save the lives of his men.

Tragedy would strike a mere five days after the actions for which Donald would be awarded his VC. While leading an attack on a machine gun nest near Contalmaison, a German sniper's bullet hit him in the head. 

Today, Donald Simpson Bell is buried at Gordon Dump Cemetery. So far, he remains the only English professional footballer to receive the Victoria Cross.

Donald’s VC was formerly displayed in the Green Howards Museum in Richmond, Yorkshire. In 2010, the Professional Footballers Association purchased the medal at auction for a reported £210,000. It now sits proudly on display in Manchester’s National Football Museum.

Share your stories of fallen sportsmen on For Evermore: our online stories archive

For Evermore: Stories of the Fallen is our online resource for sharing the memories of the Commonwealth’s war dead.

It’s open to the public to share their family histories and the tales of the service people commemorated by Commonwealth War Graves so that we may preserve their legacies beyond just a name on a headstone or a memorial.

If you have a story to tell, we’d love to hear it! Head to For Evermore: Stories of the Fallen to upload and share it for all the world to see.